The Waste Land…

“Thank God men cannot as yet fly, and lay waste the sky as well as the earth”, pondered Henry David Thoreau couple of centuries earlier, obviously consoling himself, at the same time bemoaning, the rapidly accelerating imprint of industrialization and burgeoning levels of pollution.

Mankind has since been not only flying high up the skies and between far-flung lands but the Elon Musk among them is also eyeing possibilities of colonizing outer space through inter-planetary travels, probably compelled by need to seek an exit option from steadily mounting volumes of inorganic waste and filth threatening to devour life on earth, as startlingly exposed by a recent spectacle, which may be an alarmingly recurring event at various regions around the world, of a dead elephant floating across the Pamba River. The post-mortem report attributed the death to indigestion caused by ingestion of plastic along with food as evidenced by significant traces of plastic found in the pachyderm’s alimentary canal. Located in the south Indian state of Kerala, Pamba is the third longest river in the state. The hill shrine of Sabarimala, to where there is heavy influx of pilgrims, is located at the banks of the river. The area surrounding the hill shrine is densely forested and teeming with wild life. Fortunately, the peak flow of pilgrims happens mostly during a sixty day period stretching from mid November to mid January every year. The numbers of pilgrims, however, keep rising every season disturbing the wild animals and polluting the environment with empty food cans, plastic bottles and other debris readily picked up by wild animals for traces of food. Forest conservators and veterinarians inspecting elephant trails post the pilgrim season discovered to their horror pieces of plastic, toffee-wrappers and more from samples of elephant dung drawn from sites alongside trails. The elephants, it is inferred, cannot distinguish between plastic and foodstuffs, tempted as they appear to be by the sugary and tangy taste of food residues inside left-over cans and bottles,

How to diverge from the disastrous path to which humanity seems to be headed? “If it can’t be reduced, reused, repaired, rebuilt, refurbished, refinished, resold, recycled or composted, then it should be restricted, redesigned or removed from production” was how in the last century folk singer Pete Seeger  envisioned the eco system to be sustained for the future. The spectre of countries submerging under mountains of plastic and life altogether extinguishing may no longer be in the realm of fantasy. It is extremely difficult to move around towns and cities in India, where management of waste is one of the worst anywhere in the world, without encountering humungous quantities of rubbish piled up. There is garbage billowing out of fields in the villages, on the forest floor, and in the beaches, where one’s toes are tickled by strands of plastic. Not too late in the day is the governmental mission of Swachh Bharat Abhiyan or Clean India Mission, a campaign aiming to clean up the streets, water bodies and environs of the country’s urban and rural areas. Not too late in the day too is the central government’s project to clean the Ganga that provides water to forty percent of the country’s population, and for a phased conversion of public transport from diesel to electric vehicles. Yet there is little determination to promptly implement relative policies or follow through on performance targets. Also, the government machinery is too often seen as buckling under pressure of vested interests and lacking in political will to mete out deterrent punishments to offenders.

Clearly, an effective solution to a problem of gigantic proportions cannot work without efforts on war footing from all stakeholders, of which the statutory agencies are just one. Additionally there is the general public or the consumers of goods and services, and the producers or the industry churning out goods and services to cater to the need and, nay. greed of people. When we think of waste stream management, we often think compartmentally of downstream or upstream solutions. Citizens must consume less with focus on eco-friendly products. Waste must be segregated at source and organic waste to be compulsorily composted at source. Going upstream, producers have to mandatorily switch to reusable packing like glass bottles replacing plastic. For far too long, private enterprises have been allowed to appropriate profits arising from an expanding economy and socialize the cost of coping with the waste generated. The fortune at the bottom of the pyramid in the form of mass production of FMCGs and ensuing profits has apparently been realized by many well established companies but the people at the bottom of the pyramid have been left in the lurch to grapple with detritus of that fortune.

It is high time for industry to take its social responsibility with greater seriousness as otherwise things are bound to spiral out of control. With India going digital, there is a massive and potentially hazardous e-waste generation. Even though recycling helps to harvest valuable metals from e-waste, it does not solve the problem as the residual waste is highly toxic if it is allowed to leach into the ground and water bodies. E-commerce, the other sunrise sector in India, is expected to register quantum leaps in volumes, set to grow from current usd 16 Bn to usd 200 Bn by 2026. The generation of huge amount of plastic and other packing materials that the sector is set to consume may further exacerbate an already worsening scenario. Imagine a geometrically scaling up situation with increasing consumption of a growing population; every available stretch of land and water will see rising levels of styrofoam, plastic, cardboard and metal resulting in endangered public health and environmental hazards. Global production of plastic has gone up from 1.5 million metric tons (MMT) a year in 1950 to 300 MMT per annum at present, and only 14% of such plastic is recycled. In India, more than 15000 tonnes of plastic is generated every day, a third of which remains uncollected; where the missing plastic ends up is anyone’s guess.

The only real solution is for the corporate sector to join hands with governments as producer-regulator, to control and enforce strict norms on the consumer. The need is to shift to a production and consumption protocol that is smart, innovative, and sustainable based on efficiencies across the entire life cycle of the product. The shift must focus on reducing, if not eliminating, the use of plastics, particularly single-use, wherever practical, contributing to reduction and conversion of waste to energy through aerobic and anaerobic digestion. The “clean and green Madukkarai” is an illustrative example of corporate social responsibility under the laudable initiative of ACC, the largest cement company in India, partnering in the management and recycling of waste in Madukkarai, a south Indian city suburb; the place is in the Guinness Book of World Records for the world’s largest largest recycling initiative. With the help of around 50 women, who are now called ‘Green Friends’, and a simple, scalable model, it is leading the way for efficient waste management. Next, the focus must be on redesigning products and developing alternatives. Recycling and recovery of plastics for reuse by the industry and as raw material in sectors such as construction will considerably reduce plastic waste.

Sooner or later, we will have to recognize that the Earth has rights, too, to live without pollution. What mankind must know is that human beings cannot live without Mother Earth, but the planet can live without humans. One of my early glimpses of an urbanizing society, sadly seeing increasing realization in the present and boding ill for the future, was the modernizing Eliotian world-view where civilization has been reduced to a ‘waste land’, with the land losing its fertility and ability to bring forth life, with even the living apparently suffering from some kind of spiritual wound. But how can we fix such societies? By regaining spiritual and psychological enlightenment and making peace with our demons. There is a need for deep self-realization, that we have an organic relationship with nature, duly acknowledging that human beings have an eloquent bond with all of creation. Rumi’s verse gives it lyrical expression: “Be like the sun for grace and mercy. / Be like the night to cover others’ faults. / Be like running water for generosity. / Be like death for rage and anger. / Be like the Earth for modesty. / Appear as you are. / Be as you appear”.

20 thoughts on “The Waste Land…

  1. A very timely post on the importance on waste disposal and environmental conservation, Raj. As usual, love your philosophical twist on the topic. Plastic is certainly still everywhere and very popular among consumers. Here in Australia, there is talk that grocery shops will be phasing out plastic bags and shoppers will be encouraged to bring their own reusable bags – which will undoubtedly help the environment.

    So true that e-waste is on the rise. Part of the problem of increase in waste is probably because many of us don’t know where to dispose of things like our old phones and laptops. E-waste might also be more harmful than plastic in that it can involve batteries and electrical plugs, all of which can pose fire hazards.

  2. Thanks, Mabel, for your observations. My narrative on the subject is as much science as philosophy. The threat to environment from waste build up is very real. Hence all-round awareness of the issue and check measures are of utmost importance.

  3. You touch on a subject dear to my heart, and you do it thoroughly and well. I have long advocated for humans to step down as the dominant species we believe ourselves to be unless we can act responsibly. We need to realize we cannot exist without living in harmony with this earth, nor can we thrive without other species upon her. It’s heinous really, this feeling as though we can continue to consume until all is used up, including consuming to the point of eradicating other forms of life. I do believe Mother Earth knows how to take care of herself, and if we don’t collectively wake up soon, we might undergo our own extinction. But I get ahead of myself (though perhaps not too far).

    I have a dear friend who is originally from the Philippines, and everytime Manila floods, she shakes her head and says well, the streets are so choked with debris and plastics, the storm drains plug and floods are doing increasingly greater damage as more property and lives are lost. So I can only imagine India’s problems – it’s enough to live at the end of the road in the middle of the ocean, roughly 3000 miles from anywhere and witness the detritus on remote shorelines here. Groups are constantly amassing to undertake cleanups, and our island has passed a plastic bag ban. But, as Mabel states, we don’t have clear direction for things like ewaste. And there is still far too much styrofoam and other non-recyclable waste. It’s also disheartening to see how few of us really do recycle, as we don’t have trash removal services here and must all take our rubbish to the transfer station (so we are able to witness this, firsthand). And now China says it is refusing to take Hawaii’s mixed recycling. And though it’s one source, I believe it was a main one.

    The US has zero waste communities as well – San Francisco is a model for this. Unfortunately, that leaves too many other states and communities that simply ignore the need and refuse to see the economic benefit. Gosh. Well, I’m with you, Raj – the earth has rights, too. And so I till and plant and tend our 1/2 acre and tread as lightly as possible when it comes to what we need to live our lives. The rest is too far beyond my ability to remain sane. My only hope is that with all the brilliant minds out there, solutions will be forthcoming. And I believe they are out there as we speak, but greed still drives governments and those in power are not going to go without a fight. We are living in very troubling times. Aloha, Raj.

    • Nice to see your thoughts, Bela, on a subject which I knew would hold your interest. There are countries such as Sweden, Switzerland, Austria, Germany, South Korea and Singapore, doing a reasonably efficient job with waste management and recycling. The problem is in populous countries where industrialization, consumption and environmental degradation are at unsustainable levels. The biggest culprit in many Asian countries is the corporate sector operating with scant regard to environment. For example, Ganga, stretching out 2525 kilometers, is the longest river in India. Along with its tributaries, it covers 11 states that are home to 600 million people and serves water to 40% of India’s population. The river is currently struggling to cope with the sewage waste and industrial effluents dumped into it. Given the Ganga’s importance, any further deterioration would have important ramifications. The only effective solution may clearly be for governments, industry and the general public to tackle the situation, operating as equal stakeholders. It should result in consumption that is minimal and disposal of irreducible residues after recycling (like conversion of plastic waste into granules that are mixed with tar in asphalting of roads), manufacture of products that are reusable and readily degradable, effluents properly detoxified before its is passed into water bodies etc. Every corporate body must have an ongoing R&D programme that will regularly review existing systems to figure out novel ways of manufacture to bring out products that are environment-friendly.In other words, any manufacturing facility must be sanctioned by governments based on appropriate waste disposal plan covering entire life-cycle of the product, continually monitored by the producer-consumer-regulator axis. At the macro level, waste management and recycling must be an overriding priority of global concern on which countries join together to exchange expertise and share resources. Needless to state it is an enormous task but so is the problem which if not tackled may lead us all to extinction.

      • Precisely, Raj. You are far more informed than I, or at least you are able to sort the important data and express it in a comprehensive manner. Thanks for that. I don’t subscribe to network news, but listen instead to well informed podcasts. I am going to research that source and see if I can stay better informed on global recycling/reclamation issues. You have broadened that scope for me in your comments and post, and for that I am grateful. Aloha, and looking forward to your next wp dialogue, Raj! ❤

  4. I only wish more people cared about our environment as much as you, dear Raj. Let’s not give up on sharing about our concerns and trying to positively impact the world. You are doing your part and can hold your head high for it. Sending love from Canada’s west coast.

  5. This is such a timely and crucial issue. Raj. This is a compelling description of the predicament of too much toxic waste that also provides feasible solutions and highlighted examples of initiatives that are proving to be effective. The challenge, of course, is changing how and what we consume and acting responsibly both in terms of what we buy and how we deal with our garbage. It brings to mind a hopeful old maxim – “Where there is a will, there is a way.”

    • Thanks very much, Carol, for your observations. Indeed, the way ahead is sustainable consumption and a keen awareness about and application towards responsible disposal of toxic waste.

  6. Bhutan has shown it is possible to have highest happiness quotient with zero tolerance for plastic. This is what should be emulated. Instead we emulate junk food culture. As you said rightly, the responsibility lies on us. But when the Govt continues to flourish via tainted friendships & ugly motives with corporates, the task remains uphill – and plans remain on paper.

    • Thanks Sweety for dropping by to offer your view on the subject. I agree with you. The corporate sector is having it easy in India with most of the statutory enforcement agencies turning a blind eye. Unless all hands are on board in a cooperative endeavour, the problem will only worsen from where it is now.

      • I’m sure most Indians would actually like to bring about a change. But the moment something is enforced, a rebellious streak or a ‘I’ll get thru this loophole’ mentality sticks in. So really, rather than enforcement, it should be through small scale education. Also by Govt providing cheaper options. I mean, it wont go anywhere if cloth bags are 10 times costlier than plastic.

      • No need of cloth bags; economically viable jute bags will more than suffice. Before plastic came into the picture, jute bags (to be used for grocery shopping) was readily available in all households and used / reused by people. The initiative must come at the level of local bodies and escalate upwards and across all sectors.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s